Children's Online Safety Laws Don't Ask Children

Image of author
By Tech Writer and VPN Researcher Gintarė Mažonaitė
Last updated: 20 November, 2026
A group of children talking to adults in a school hallway.

Key Takeaways

  • The Convention on the Rights of the Child gives children a right to be heard in matters affecting them and to have their views taken seriously.

  • Online safety legislation affects children's daily lives more than almost any other policy area, and consults them less than almost any other.

  • Rules built without that input produce predictable failures, including identity checks that exclude children who have no documents.

  • The risks to children online are real. The objection is to how the response gets designed, not to the goal.

Today, November 20th, is World Children's Day, marking the adoption of the Convention on the Rights of the Child in 1989.

The Convention is usually invoked in digital policy debates for its protection clauses. Children have a right to be safeguarded from exploitation and harm, which is true and which does real work in these arguments.

There's another article that comes up far less often. Children have the right to express their views freely in matters affecting them, and to have those views given weight according to their age and maturity.

Online safety law affects children's daily lives more directly than most policy does. It also consults them less than most policy. That gap is exactly what we’re talking about today.

The Right That Gets Skipped

The right for children to participate isn’t a soft aspiration. It sits alongside the protection rights in the same document, and the UN committee that interprets the Convention has published guidance specifically on how children's rights apply in digital environments.

What the convention asks for is straightforward: involve children in decisions about the spaces they occupy. What happens in practice is that adults identify a harm, adults design a measure, adults debate it, and children face the result when it arrives.

Now, I don't think this is malicious. Consulting children is slower, harder to organize, and produces messier input than commissioning a report. It's also the thing the Convention asks for, and skipping it has consequences that show up later in the design.

What Gets Built Without Asking

The clearest example is age and identity verification. A measure intended to keep children away from certain content requires all users to prove their age. The assumption is that a child who can't verify simply doesn't get in, which is the intended outcome.

The unintended outcome affects children who can't verify anything. Children in care, children in families without stable documentation, undocumented migrant children, and children in places where birth registration is incomplete. They aren't blocked from one category of content. They're blocked from services that happen to sit behind the same check.

Those often include the services they most need. Educational platforms. Helplines. Support communities. Age verification has been expanding well past adult content into social media, app stores, and operating systems, which widens the set of things a child without papers can't reach.

Anyone who had asked a children's services organization would have raised this in the first meeting. The problem isn't that it's hard to foresee. It's that the people who could foresee it weren't in the room.

The Encryption Case Is the Sharpest Version

The same pattern produces a more serious version in proposals to scan private messages. The argument for scanning is about protecting children, and the harm it targets is genuine and severe. Nobody sensible disputes that child sexual abuse material is a crisis or that detecting it matters.

The objection is about what else a general scanning capability does, and here the children's perspective is directly relevant.

A child experiencing abuse at home needs a private channel to reach someone outside the home. A young person working out their identity in an unsupportive environment needs to ask questions without those questions being visible. A teenager in a controlling situation needs communication that isn't monitored. Private messaging isn’t incidental for these children. It's the mechanism by which they get help.

A measure that removes confidentiality from everyone's messages removes it from theirs too. That tradeoff is at least arguable, but it should be argued with the children who depend on that channel rather than only about them. We've written before about how youth safety laws collide with youth rights, and this is the sharpest example.

What This Day Is Actually For

Children face real risks online. Exploitation, contact from adults who shouldn't be contacting them, content they're not equipped for, and platforms designed to hold their fragile attention spans regardless of effect. Those aren’t invented problems, and the people working to solve them aren’t villains.

The argument is more niche. A Convention that says children have a right to be heard in matters affecting them is being used to justify measures designed without hearing them. That's not a minor procedural complaint. It produces worse policy, as the documentation gap and the encryption tradeoff both show.

World Children's Day exists to mark a document that treats children as rights-holders rather than as objects of concern. Applied to digital policy, the test is simple: when a government writes rules about children's internet use, did it ask any?


Share on
Facebook share Twitter share Reddit share Linkedin share

Be part of the resistance, quietly.

awareness campaign banner img
Image of author
Gintarė Mažonaitė
Tech Writer and VPN Researcher

Gintarė is a cybersecurity writer at Mysterium VPN, where she explores online privacy, VPN technology, and the latest digital threats in editorial pieces. With hands-on experience researching and writing about data protection and digital freedom, Gintarė makes complex security topics accessible and actionable.

Read our editorial policy here.

Read more by this author